VOICE OF DETROIT: The city's independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought

Cops killed at least 20 Detroiters, and raped dozens more, during Ella Bully-Cummings’ tenure as police chief

 Do Detroiters want HER on 36^th District Court bench? 

By Diane Bukowski 

Detroit – Ella Bully Cummings has been rather quiet about her run for 36^th District Court Judge so far—no signs in the streets, no pep rallies—YET. The chief publicity she has received was a positive interview in The Michigan Citizen, at

http://michigancitizen.com/bullycummings-runs-for-th-district-p8661-74.htm.

But some believe she will launch a blitzkrieg campaign in the coming week, following a blizzard of media ads that have attacked incumbent 36^TH District Court women judges for being “soft on crime.”

Ella Bully-Cummings was Detroit’s chief of police under Kwame Kilpatrick from 2003 through 2008, returning from retirement after a life-long career in the DPD.  At the time, Bully-Cummings was hailed as one of only four female top cops in the U.S.

Stop killer cops from Oakland to Detroit

But during her tenure, at least 21 Detroiters died at the hands of Detroit police officers with her blessings, since she neither disciplined nor discharged the cops involved. Attorneys and families of the victims have claimed the deaths were in fact unjustified homicides.

Most of these deaths were reported by this author in the pages of The Michigan Citizen.

Cummings also condoned rapes by cops and false prosecutions, in addition to failing to protect Detroiters from death at the hands of state troopers and other law enforcement agents.

The killing of Tommie Staples, Jr. in June, 2008 by officers Steven Kopp and Barron Townsend is a prime example of events that took place under Bully-Cummings’ watch.

The Staples family includes (l-r, rear) son Brian Staples, wife Jacquelyn Porter, Tommy Staples, Jr. (shot to death by police), son Tommy Staples III; (l-r, front), grandchildren Davion and Darion, and daughter Ashley Staples.

Staples’ family won a $2.5 million settlement from the city July 27, indicating even the city believes his death in June, 2008 was unjustified (see earlier VOD story on Staples settlement in September archives).

“This is another example of how the Detroit Police Department fails to investigate cases involving the use of excessive force, to reconcile inconsistent evidence and scrutinize officers,” the family’s attorney David Robinson told this reporter. “No discipline has been brought against these officers for Tommie Staples’ death. It is inexcusable that the department is still non-compliant after seven years of federal oversight.”

Robinson blasted Cummings in the lawsuit, saying she participated in a cover-up.   Continue reading →

By Diane Bukowski 

PART I – Board meeting Oct. 14 

DPS Czar Robert Bobb as he is shouted off stage at board meeting 10 14 10

DETROIT – At the Detroit Board of Education’s monthly meeting Oct. 14, Robert Bobb, state-appointed czar of the Detroit Public Schools, announced his  Plan A-Plan B for the district’s post-Bobb era next year, which proposes to complete the destruction of the district begun in 1999 by state government.  He said he will present it to the state Nov. 15, while he still has exclusive control of the district. 

(See analysis of Bobb’s plan in PART TWO. Also see VOD story, “DPS Caught in Devil’s Triangle,” (9/13). That story explained that the banks take 90 percent of every DPS per-pupil school aid dollar, that there will soon be more charter schools than public schools in Detroit, and that Detroit students are treated as 3/5 of person under state funding formulas, a throwback to slavery times. All of this has been ignored by the board, city and state leadership.) 

During the meeting, Board president Anthony Adams and other board leaders evidently had mended fences with Bobb since the community’s defeat of a proposed mayoral takeover of DPS, during which board leaders were temporarily viewed as heroes. 

This time, however, Bobb and most of the board appeared ready and raring to finish off DPS on their own together, Katrina-style. 

DPS parent Rico Villareal says district is leaving bilingual children and teachers behind

Bobb and Adams paid little attention to parent Rico Villareal’s  10-minute pre-scheduled presentation at the beginning of the meeting. Villareal denounced the district’s mistreatment of bilingual children and teachers, among other matters. 

“Bilingual child are being left behind,” Villareal said. “But we are fighting not only for them, but for all the children that have been left behind in DPS. Nothing has changed. At the beginning of the year, my child’s school was short 15 teachers, and no books had been delivered. There are no bilingual teachers; my child, who is bilingual, has to sit in class and translate for another child who understands no English.  There was a Parent Resource Center at Southwestern High School, now it’s gone. 

“Every morning at Clippert Elementary, there are 600 kids standing outside in line waiting to go through the metal detectors because there is only one guard. I go to work at 8 a.m. I drop my child off there at 7:40 a.m. but he has been marked tardy 10 times because it takes him so long to get into the school. Where has all the money gone?” 

The next speaker was Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy. Continue reading →

History of Labor’s Fighting Defense of Civil Liberties and Free Speech

16 Oct 10
By Joe Burns

 Important labor groups are speaking out against the recent spate of federal attacks on the civil liberties of U.S. peace and labor activists.. On October 1, 2010, the convention of AFSCME Council 5, representing 46,000 public employees in Minnesota, passed a resolution objecting to recent FBI raids of prominent peace and labor rights activists in Minneapolis and Chicago. Likewise, the San Francisco Central Labor Council delegates meeting voted on September 27 to denounce the raids and “participate in the ongoing movement to defend our civil rights and civil liberties from FBI infringement.”

Kidnapped Africans, forced to labor as slaves, were the first workers in this country to rebel; in painting, Denmark Vesey plots rebellion against slaveholders, for which he was later hanged

On September 24, the FBI raided the homes of seven activists, seizing computers, cell phones and documents. The FBI also raided the offices of the Twin Cities Anti-War Committee, seizing their computer containing a database of supporters. The peace movement nationally has roundly condemned the FBI for attempting to silence dissent. In the weeks following the raids, demonstrators protested in dozens of US cities.  

The FBI also issued subpoenas requiring the activists to testify before a grand jury in Chicago. Many of those subpoenaed are trade unionists. The AFSCME Council 5 resolution noted that four of the subpoenaed activists were members in good standing of ASCME Council 5. The San Francisco CLC resolution made note that among the Chicago activists subpoenaed was Joe Iosbaker, a longtime SEIU chief steward at the University of Illinois Chicago and a stalwart in the Chicago labor solidarity scene.

Industrial Workers of the World organizer Joe Hill was framed and hanged by the government in 1901

They are also workers, parents and homeowners—real people who face  real consequences and a terrible choice: If they refuse to cooperate with this illegitimate fishing expedition, they face imprisonment. This jeopardizes their jobs, their homes and their families. All have informed the grand jury they will refuse to testify.  

The FBI raids came the same week the Department of Justice’s Office of Inspector General criticized the FBI (PDF link) for engaging in surveillance of domestic peace groups, including the pacifist Merton Center. The report found no compelling reason for the FBI infiltrating and conducting surveillance of these domestic groups.  

Continue reading →

Masjif El-Haqq members after prayer Oct. 14, including (center to right) Imam's children Jamil Carswell, Omar Regan and Bernice Regan; other members said they have vowed to continue Imam Luqman Abdullah's peaceful mission of feeding and sheltering their neighbors, and campaigning for the exoneration of Imam Jamil Al-Amin

DETROIT – Family members of Imam Luqman Abdullah, along with religious and civil rights leaders, have reacted with shock and anger to the U.S. Department of Justice’s exoneration of four FBI agents who shot the Imam to death Oct. 28, 2009. 

Imam Abdullah, leader of the Masjid El-Haqq mosque in Detroit, sustained 21 gunshot wounds, a broken arm, and numerous lacerations to his face and upper body, which one medical examiner said resulted from police dog bites. Sixty-six federal agents, as well as local and international law enforcement officials, were involved in the raid which ended with his death. 

Partial warehouse video of raid (there were no FBI cameras utilized according to Cox report); it shows an Islamic-garbed man and at least a half-dozen others retreating into trailer after FBI incursion; several raise hands to surrender and lie down; the Islamic-garbed man stands for a few seconds more, then also lies down; it is unclear if he does so voluntarily or was shot at this point; two of the men are dragged out by agents, meaning several others remained in trailer, but were never interviewed by DOJ regarding what they observed of Imam's shooting; nothing is seen of events in trailer afterwards; why did no FBI agent carry audio/video as Imam was assassinated?

“The evidence does not reveal a violation of any applicable federal criminal civil rights statutes,” the report, issued by the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division Oct. 13, declared. “Accordingly, this matter will be returned to the FBI to complete its administrative review.” 

Imam Dawud Walid, head of the Michigan chapter of the Council on Islamic and American Relations (CAIR) said that his organization is considering bringing charges of human rights violations to the United Nations if no justice is received from the U.S. government. 

Link

http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid193962165001?bctid=645374944001

“When a person is killed unjustly in a military-style operation, it is not only his civil rights, but his human rights that are violated,” Imam Walid said. He said CAIR and the Imam’s family are also considering bringing a wrongful death lawsuit. 

Imam Abdullah, 53, was a respected leader in the desperately poor west-side Detroit neighborhood where his mosque is located, according to many who benefited from the food, clothing and shelter that Masjid El-Haqq provided to them. The Imam has been lauded locally, nationally and globally by Muslims and Blacks, including religious leaders of different faiths. 

Twenty of those leaders sent a letter to President Barack Obama in May demanding the DOJ civil rights investigation. 

The four federal agents cited in the DOJ report were among 66 who participated in a raid on a warehouse in Dearborn, a Detroit suburb, during which the Imam was killed. Three of those four belonged to a special squad of 14 counterterrorism and hostage situation agents from FBI headquarters in Virginia which took part in the raid, according to the government. 

According to the Dearborn Police, officers with the U.S. Border Patrol, Immigration Customs Enforcement, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, the Wayne County Sheriff’s Department, the Detroit Police as well as the Dearborn Police participated in the operation.

The raid culminated a two-year FBI undercover investigation of the Imam’s mosque, which turned up no terrorism-related charges, only petty theft and weapons-related violations. The indictment was issued the day before the Imam’s death and was based largely on reports by FBI-paid infiltrators of alleged conversations with the Imam and his followers. Almost none of of the conversations were taped. 

Ten mosque members were arrested during and after the raid and have allegedly now pled guilty to the minor charges. 

Omar Regan and brother Jamil Carswell protest outside ALPACT dinner co-chaired by Detroit FBI head Andrew Arena Nov. 19, 2009; inside wining and dining with the FBI were Mayor Dave Bing, members of the Detroit NAACP, CAIR, the Coalition Against Police Brutality, and other liberal groups who co-sponsored the dinner and met on a regular basis with the FBI and numerous law enforcement agencies for nine years, allegedly to stop racial profilling after 9/11

“We’re hurt and we’re disappointed,” Omar Regan, 35, one of the Imam’s 13 children, said. “We believe they closed the case prematurely. There is no proof in their report that my father had a gun, and no video or photos of his shooting. There were no handprints on the gun, no DNA evidence, no gunpowder stippling. They only took the word of the four agents.” 

Imam Walid said that he and other representatives of the family and community met for three hours with DOJ Civil Rights division representative Thomas Perez after the report was issued. 

“We found out that the DOJ, despite clearing the FBI, found no forensic evidence to corroborate the statement that the Imam had a firearm. I informed Mr. Perez it would have been more prudent to delay the results until they get testimony from the four individuals from the Imam’s mosque who were nearby when he was killed. There is no explanation of how he was shot in the back. I am very disappointed.”  Continue reading →

Democratic gubernatorial candidate Virg Bernero and other supports of two-year foreclosure moratorium, Chase boycott

Major banks’ mortgage fraud schemes exposed across U.S.

 

By Diane Bukowski 

DETROIT – As a flood of mortgage fraud exposures engulfed the nation’s largest banks, Michigan’s Democratic gubernatorial candidate Virg Bernero has pledged today that he would impose a two-year halt to all foreclosures upon assuming office in 2011. 

“I have fought the banks tooth and nail,” Bernero told a cheering audience sporting AFSCME Council 25 t-shirts at an Oct. 8 press conference called by the newly formed “People Before Banks” Coalition.  

“I see by today’s newspapers that the Bank of America has just halted all foreclosures in 50 states, as an investigation into the fraudulent practices of the banks and lenders widens. Yesterday, I confronted bank CEO’s in person at the Detroit Economic Club (DEC), telling them, ‘If you do right by the people, you’ll get along with me.’”

Standing ovation for Bernero, People Before Banks

Bernero, mayor of Lansing, the state capitol, first announced his fight against the banks last July. He called for Michigan’s governor and treasurer to pull more than $1 billion in state deposits from JP Morgan Chase. He said that despite the government’s payment of $25 billion in TARP (Troubled Asset Relief Program) bailout tax dollars, the bank has continued to redline Michigan small businesses, driving some out of business. 

On Oct. 7, local news media reported that Bernero “stunned” the audience at the DEC forum. 

“If you are part of the Wall Street breed that runs over people for ever-growing profits and growing bonuses, you will have a problem, because I’ve had it,” he told the businessmen who comprise the Club’s membership. “We’re up to here with it. Enough is enough.” 

Accused of “bullying” the members of the Club, he told a Detroit Free Press reporter, “I’ll tell you who feels bullied. It’s people that have been thrown out of their homes, especially by mistake, fraudulently. It’s 600 a day in Michigan, that’s who’s being bullied and that’s got to be stopped immediately, now.” 

GRASS ROOTS PUSHED POLITICIANS TO TAKE STANCE AGAINST BANKS

The astounding anti-bank stance adopted by Bernero and other government officials has exploded in the wake of groundbreaking efforts by Detroit’s Moratorium NOW! Coalition against Foreclosures, Evictions, and Shut-offs. It was taken up nationally by the United Auto Workers and the Farm Labor Organizing Committee in a march of thousands in Detroit Aug. 28 and later in Washington Oct. 2.  Continue reading →

Mumia Abu-Jamal: Journalism in prison

The nearly 29-year struggle to free political prisoner Mumia Abu-Jamal faces a critical juncture with the announcement that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit will review Abu-Jamal’s death sentence on Nov. 9. It is imperative that all who stand for justice and against racism and state repression pack the courtroom in Philadelphia.

In 2008 the Third Circuit Court granted Abu-Jamal a new sentencing hearing based on flawed jury instructions in the sentencing phase of his 1982 trial. However, on Jan. 19 of this year, the U.S. Supreme Court granted the Philadelphia district attorney’s petition for a review of a 2001 ruling by federal Judge William Yohn that overturned Abu-Jamal’s death penalty but not his conviction.

The Supreme Court went against Yohn’s decision as well as the 2008 Third Circuit ruling granting a new sentencing-phase jury trial to decide if Abu-Jamal’s death penalty was to be reinstated. In the week before the Jan. 19 decision the Supreme Court ruled on Smith v. Spisak, a case that also involved questionable instructions to the jury during the sentencing phase, although the case differs from Abu-Jamal’s in both legal and political aspects.

Ruling in white supremacist’s case used against Mumia

Neo-Nazi and white supremacist Frank Spisak killed three people and then bragged about it in court. Abu-Jamal, a former Black Panther organizer, was convicted of killing Philadelphia police officer Daniel Faulkner on Dec. 9, 1981, but has always maintained his innocence. Several prosecution witnesses from his 1982 trial have since recanted their testimony.

Spisak’s lawyers had appealed based on the 1988 Supreme Court ruling in Mills v. Maryland, which addresses confusing jury instructions. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals had overturned Spisak’s sentence based on Mills, but the U.S. Supreme Court decided the standard did not apply in Abu-Jamal’s case.

It would appear that the Supreme Court, which had the district attorney’s appeal of Yohn’s decision since 2001, was waiting for a case like Spisak’s so they could justify their reversal in Abu-Jamal’s case, even though the two cases and the two defendants differ as night from day. Even though Abu-Jamal’s case met the Mills standard, the Supreme Court refused to apply it, in what was clearly a decision motivated by politics and not law. Continue reading →

"Momma's happy now!" Barrow with supporters after court hearing, including Gwen Gaines in T-shirt

Former candidate seeks Bing’s immediate removal due to massive irregulaties in vote

By Diane Bukowski

DETROIT, Oct. 4  — Just as a  tide of anger against Mayor Dave Bing’s urban removal plans is rising, the Michigan Court of Appeals has said it will hear  former mayoral candidate Tom Barrow’s suit challenging Bing’s right to be Mayor on Nov. 2. 

Ironically, that is election day, an official holiday for city employees. Bing and the City Council just imposed a concession contract on AFSCME workers, the last hold-outs, after months of their angry protests at the Coleman A. Young Center. 

Al Garrett, president of Michigan AFSCME Council 25, was excited when informed of the announcement. 

 “I’ll be at the polls and the appeals court and we’ll get a letter out to our members. We”ll be happy to get to the bottom of this–there have been too many problems with elections in Detroit for too long. And secretly–and you can print this, I’m rooting for Barrow.” 

Nearly all city unions endorsed Barrow in last year’s election. 

The hearing, by a panel of three judges,  is open to the public and will take place at the state’s Cadillac Place building  (the old GM building on W. Grand Blvd. and Second) at 11 a.m on the 14th floor. 

Barrow said the appeals judges assigned to the case are Deborah Servitto, appointed by Governor James Blanchard, Pat D’Onofrio, appointed by Governor Jennifer Granholm, and Brian Zahra. 

 “The underlying facts in this case have never before happened in the United States,” said Barrow’s campaign manager Geoffrey Garfield. “Because of the paucity of modern case law, many legal observers expect the Court’s decision to establish precedent for decades to come as this case is being monitored all over the country.’

Barrow supporters pack recount hearing Dec. 23

He said the Wayne County Board of Canvassers ruled “100 percent of Detroit’s 41,485 absentee ballots could not be recounted; that another 8,001 ballots from neighborhood precincts also could not be recounted; and that 9,649 ballots could not be determined to have been cast in compliance with state law requiring polls to open at 7am and remain open until 8pm.. Thus 59,135 , or 54.9% of the 114,718 ballots cast for mayor were tainted in an election where the margin to alter the outcome of the race was 9,692, nearly 7 times less than the number of irregular ballots. These facts alone should have our citizens up in arms and demanding accountability from Detroit election officials!”

Barrow said, “This law suit is not sour grapes or a refusal to accept an election loss, rather it’s about 59,135 of 114,718 ballots which the public does not know were un-recountable and irregular.  It is clear that Mr.  Bing was not validly elected,  rather only the passage of time gives the public a false impression of legitimacy.”  Continue reading →

Imam Luqman Adbullah, leader of the Masjid El-Haqq mosque

Imam shot 21 times as he lay prone; no fingerprints on gun he allegedly fired 

By Diane Bukowski 

DETROIT – Michigan’s Attorney General Mike Cox declared Sept. 30  that FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigation) agents violated “no Michigan laws” when they shot Imam Luqman Abdullah, leader of Detroit’s Masjid El-Haqq mosque, to death Oct. 28, 2009. 

Agents shot Imam Abdullah 21 times as he lay on his stomach on the floor, according to a report released by Mr. Cox’s office. The report and attached agent statements claim Imam Abdullah refused orders to show his hands, which were under his body, and then opened fire on an FBI dog which was biting him, before the agents killed him. 

“My office’s review found undisputed evidence that Mr. Abdullah resisted arrest and fired a gun first in the direction of the agents,” Mr. Cox said.  “Under Michigan law, law enforcement agents are justified in using deadly force in these types of situations, and therefore we found no crimes.” 

Mr. Cox’s office said they conducted 82 interviews, reviewed 1600 pages of U.S. Justice Department files, and FBI and Dearborn Police Department video recordings. 

The report says no fingerprints were found on the gun allegedly used by the Imam. 

Imam Abullah's son Omar Regan (speaking) and Jamil Carswell (to his left) lead protest against their father's murder outside the Federal McNamara Building 11 4 09

“The 9 mm firearm recovered from Abdullah was analyzed by the FBI lab,” Mr. Cox’s office said. “There were no usable latent prints found on the firearm—a finding not uncommon with firearms.” 

The report does not say an examination of the Imam’s hands or body for gunshot residue took place. During a press conference Feb. 1, Wayne County Medical Examiner Carl Schmidt said that the Imam’s hands were not bagged to preserve such evidence. 

The agents killed Imam Abdullah during a “sting” at a warehouse in suburban Dearborn, planned months beforehand, and repeatedly rehearsed, according to the report. Twenty-nine agents took part in the warehouse. Ten other mosque members were arrested and still face federal theft and weapons charges. 

Detroit police raided Masjid El-Haqq the same day. The report says a “Detroit SWAT team” also participated in the Dearborn ambush, along with Dearborn police.

Members of Imam's Mosque pray during protest outside ALPACT Dinner featuring Detroit FBI head Andrew Arena Nov. 2009

Imam Abdullah’s son Omar Regan said he and his family are not surprised at what they consider a complete whitewash.

“They told on themselves,” Mr. Regan said. “They admitted he complied with their orders and laid on his stomach. They had cameras in the warehouse, but the agents who set the scene up put TV’s on a pallet in front of where my father was lying, so you very conveniently don’t see his killing on video. Why would you have to sic a dog on a man lying on the ground when you have 29 agents to subdue him?” 

The 21 gunshots pulverized virtually all the Imam’s organs. His arm was broken, and his mouth severely lacerated by the dog, according to a second autopsy commissioned by the Michigan Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR).  Continue reading →

AFSCME workers march at CAYMC

•  26 unpaid furlough days per year for 3 years (total 78 days) – equal to a three-year, 10% pay cut.\
• If your department decides to work you on some furlough days, Bing could force you to take unpaid furlough days at some other point within the year to make it up.
• If your spouse has health insurance available from his/her employer (regardless of how substandard or overpriced) the imposed contract requires that your spouse purchase their employer’s insurance as their primary insurance. The city worker could choose to pay to insure their spouse but that would be secondary insurance. This would cost many families thousands of extra dollars per year.
• No longevity pay.
• Overtime would not start until after you’ve worked 40 hours in a work week (sick time, O.J.I., jury duty, furlough days, etc. would not count as hours worked. For example, if you worked a double shift, management could schedule you off on an unpaid furlough day later in the pay period and you’d only get a straight 40 hour check for that week.
• If you’re scheduled off work on a holiday, but call in sick your last scheduled work day before or the day after the holiday, you won’t get paid for the holiday.
• When and if the payroll system is able to make the adjustments, management may insist that all paychecks be issued bi-weekly with mandatory direct deposit.
• Tuition refund eliminated for 3 years; after that it would only be available with 3 years seniority.
• There will be further negotiations and arbitration regarding City’s plan to enact generally harsher city-wide disciplinary guidelines, including longer suspensions.
• More limits on name brand drugs with the final decision made by health insurance companies. No more drugs for fertility or sexual dysfunction.
• Retiree health care benefits will now match current employee benefits; if you remarry after retiring, your new spouse and /or new dependents would no longer be covered by health insurance.     Continue reading →